Head 2 Head matchups
All-time game-by-game detail
| 1 | 9/13/1958 | North Allegheny | 24-7 | W | A | 1st game / 1st Victory |
| 2 | 9/20/1958 | Bellmar | 7-7 | T | H | Game played at Wilmerding Stadium 1st Home Game |
| 3 | 9/26/1958 | Swissvale | 6-0 | W | A | |
| 4 | 10/4/1958 | Freedom | 39-6 | W | H | Game played at Wilmerding Stadium |
| 5 | 10/11/1958 | Fifth Avenue | 13-0 | W | H | Game played at Wilmerding Stadium |
| 6 | 10/17/1958 | Kittanning | 24-13 | W | H | Game played at Wilmerding Stadium |
| 7 | 10/24/1958 | Tarentum | 33-7 | W | A | |
| 8 | 11/1/1958 | Oakmont | 13-19 | L | H | Game played at Wilmerding Stadium |
| 9 | 11/7/1958 | Hopewell | 25-14 | W | H | Game played at Wilmerding Stadium Final game of first season. |
| 10 | 9/12/1959 | Swissvale | 7-6 | W | H | 1st game at Gateway High School stadium |
| 11 | 9/18/1959 | Bellmar | 7-13 | L | A | Bellmar is in Belle Vernon, PA |
| 12 | 9/25/1959 | Beth-Center | 13-7 | W | A | Beth-Center is in Fredericktown, PA |
| 13 | 10/2/1959 | Norwin | 7-27 | L | A | |
| 14 | 10/10/1959 | Penn Hills | 0-26 | L | H | First game against Penn Hills, in Gateway's second season. Game played on a Saturday, in the 2nd ever home game at Gateway. |
| 15 | 10/16/1959 | Kittanning | 20-14 | W | A | |
| 16 | 10/24/1959 | Mon Valley | 27-7 | W | H | |
| 17 | 10/31/1959 | Oakmont | 6-6 | T | H | |
| 18 | 11/7/1959 | Elizabeth Forward | 25-14 | W | A | |
| 19 | 8/10/1960 | Swissvale | 12-26 | L | A | |
| 20 | 9/17/1960 | North Allegheny | 19-7 | W | A | |
| 21 | 9/24/1960 | Beth-Center | 18-0 | W | H | |
| 22 | 10/1/1960 | Norwin | 13-28 | L | H | |
| 23 | 10/7/1960 | Penn Hills | 13-6 | W | A | |
| 24 | 10/14/1960 | West Mifflin North | 21-6 | W | A | |
| 25 | 10/21/1960 | North Hills | 25-14 | W | A | |
| 26 | 10/28/1960 | Shaler | 20-0 | W | H | |
| 27 | 11/5/1960 | Elizabeth Forward | 6-6 | T | H | |
| 28 | 9/8/1961 | Bethel Park | 0-13 | L | A | |
| 29 | 9/16/1961 | North Allegheny | 18-6 | W | H | |
| 30 | 9/22/1961 | Beth-Center | 0-14 | L | H | |
| 31 | 9/29/1961 | Norwin | 14-7 | W | A | |
| 32 | 10/5/1961 | Penn Hills | 7-27 | L | H | |
| 33 | 10/14/1961 | West Mifflin North | 0-33 | L | H | |
| 34 | 10/20/1961 | North Hills | 40-7 | W | H | |
| 35 | 10/28/1961 | Shaler | 0-7 | L | A | |
| 36 | 11/3/1961 | Mt. Pleasant | 13-25 | L | A | |
| 37 | 11/11/1961 | Elizabeth Forward | 14-25 | L | A | |
| 38 | 9/8/1962 | Bethel Park | 14-0 | W | H | Game postponed by light failure |
| 39 | 9/15/1962 | North Allegheny | 0-7 | L | A | |
| 40 | 9/21/1962 | Beth-Center | 0-0 | T | A | |
| 41 | 9/28/1962 | Norwin | 7-21 | L | H | |
| 42 | 10/6/1962 | Penn Hills | 13-38 | L | A | |
| 43 | 10/13/1962 | West Mifflin North | 0-28 | L | A | |
| 44 | 10/19/1962 | North Hills | 18-14 | W | A | |
| 45 | 10/26/1962 | Shaler | 14-6 | W | H | |
| 46 | 11/2/1962 | Derry | 12-32 | L | H | |
| 47 | 11/9/1962 | Elizabeth Forward | 6-7 | L | H | |
| 48 | 9/6/1963 | Gladstone | 19-16 | W | H | |
| 49 | 9/13/1963 | North Allegheny | 33-18 | W | H | |
| 50 | 9/21/1963 | Greensburg Central Catholic | 27-13 | W | A | |
| 51 | 9/28/1963 | Braddock | 26-14 | W | A | |
| 52 | 10/3/1963 | Penn Hills | 7-26 | L | H | |
| 53 | 10/11/1963 | West Mifflin North | 13-47 | L | H | |
| 54 | 10/18/1963 | North Hills | 13-32 | L | H | |
| 55 | 10/25/1963 | Shaler | 0-7 | L | A | |
| 56 | 11/1/1963 | Derry | 7-12 | L | A | |
| 57 | 9/11/1964 | Gladstone | 18-0 | W | H | |
| 58 | 9/19/1964 | North Allegheny | 13-0 | W | A | |
| 59 | 9/25/1964 | Greensburg Central Catholic | 7-20 | L | H | |
| 60 | 10/2/1964 | Westinghouse Memorial - Wilmerding | 0-19 | L | H | |
| 61 | 10/9/1964 | Penn Hills | 19-13 | W | A | |
| 62 | 10/16/1964 | West Mifflin North | 19-34 | L | A | |
| 63 | 10/23/1964 | North Hills | 34-19 | W | A | |
| 64 | 10/30/1964 | Shaler | 6-7 | L | H | |
| 65 | 11/6/1964 | Franklin Regional | 38-14 | W | H | |
| 66 | 9/10/1965 | Braddock | 13-2 | W | H | |
| 67 | 9/17/1965 | North Allegheny | 20-12 | W | H | |
| 68 | 9/24/1965 | Greensburg Central Catholic | 26-7 | W | A | |
| 69 | 10/1/1965 | Westinghouse Memorial - Wilmerding | 13-6 | W | A | |
| 70 | 10/7/1965 | Penn Hills | 13-7 | W | H | Game played at Turtle Creek Stadium |
| 71 | 10/15/1965 | Wilkinsburg | 20-6 | W | H | |
| 72 | 10/22/1965 | North Hills | 13-0 | W | H | |
| 73 | 10/29/1965 | Shaler | 25-0 | W | A | |
| 74 | 11/6/1965 | Churchill | 13-6 | W | A | First undefeated season |
| 75 | 9/9/1966 | Plum | 6-0 | W | H | |
| 76 | 9/17/1966 | North Allegheny | 33-7 | W | A | |
| 77 | 9/23/1966 | Derry | 19-39 | L | A | |
| 78 | 9/30/1966 | Westinghouse Memorial - Wilmerding | 12-6 | W | H | |
| 79 | 10/8/1966 | Penn Hills | 6-38 | L | A | |
| 80 | 10/14/1966 | Bethel Park | 12-20 | L | ||
| 81 | 10/21/1966 | North Hills | 7-0 | W | A | |
| 82 | 10/28/1966 | Shaler | 25-0 | W | H | |
| 83 | 11/4/1966 | Churchill | 0-14 | L | H | |
| 84 | 9/8/1967 | Plum | 21-14 | W | A | |
| 85 | 9/15/1967 | North Allegheny | 25-6 | W | H | |
| 86 | 9/22/1967 | Derry | 12-27 | L | H | |
| 87 | 9/30/1967 | Westinghouse Memorial - Wilmerding | 13-7 | W | A | |
| 88 | 10/6/1967 | Penn Hills | 0-7 | L | H | |
| 89 | 10/13/1967 | Bethel Park | 25-6 | W | A | |
| 90 | 10/20/1967 | North Hills | 19-7 | W | H | |
| 91 | 10/27/1967 | Shaler | 20-7 | W | A | |
| 92 | 11/4/1967 | Churchill | 0-13 | L | A | |
| 93 | 9/6/1968 | Keystone Oaks | 12-6 | W | H | |
| 94 | 9/14/1968 | North Allegheny | 7-0 | W | A | Game played at 10:30am |
| 95 | 9/20/1968 | Derry | 40-7 | W | A | |
| 96 | 9/27/1968 | Westinghouse Memorial - Wilmerding | 21-6 | W | H | |
| 97 | 10/5/1968 | Penn Hills | 6-7 | L | A | Played at 10:30am |
| 98 | 10/11/1968 | Sto-Rox | 26-0 | W | A | |
| 99 | 10/18/1968 | North Hills | 20-0 | W | H | |
| 100 | 10/25/1968 | Shaler | 26-14 | W | H | |
| 101 | 11/2/1968 | Churchill | 13-0 | W | A | |
| 102 | 9/6/1969 | Fox Chapel | 27-0 | W | A | Teachers Strike |
| 103 | 9/12/1969 | North Allegheny | 22-6 | W | A | Moved to NA due to Teachers Strike |
| 104 | 9/20/1969 | Burrell | 34-6 | W | H | Played Saturday night; end of teachers strike |
| 105 | 9/26/1969 | North Hills | 32-0 | W | A | |
| 106 | 10/3/1969 | Upper St. Clair | 25-8 | W | A | |
| 107 | 10/10/1969 | Moon | 49-0 | W | H | |
| 108 | 10/17/1969 | Churchill | 30-0 | W | H | |
| 109 | 10/24/1969 | Shaler | 37-16 | W | A | |
| 110 | 11/1/1969 | East Allegheny | 33-13 | W | A | |
| 111 | 11/29/1969 | Altoona | 22-15 | W | N | Game played at Pitt Stadium WPIAL AA Title Game - First WPIAL Title |
| 112 | 9/11/1970 | Fox Chapel | 28-6 | W | H | |
| 113 | 9/19/1970 | North Allegheny | 20-20 | T | A | |
| 114 | 9/26/1970 | Burrell | 21-6 | W | A | |
| 115 | 10/2/1970 | North Hills | 6-21 | L | H | |
| 116 | 10/10/1970 | Plum | 26-0 | W | A | Game was postponed from Friday 10/9/1970 due to rain |
| 117 | 10/16/1970 | Moon | 33-7 | W | A | |
| 118 | 10/24/1970 | Churchill | 13-0 | W | A | |
| 119 | 11/2/1970 | Shaler | 20-8 | W | H | Game postponed from 10/30/1970 due to rain |
| 120 | 11/6/1970 | East Allegheny | 0-32 | L | H | |
| 121 | 9/10/1971 | Seneca Valley | 14-7 | W | H | |
| 122 | 9/17/1971 | Moon | 28-6 | W | H | |
| 123 | 9/24/1971 | East Allegheny | 41-0 | W | H | |
| 124 | 10/2/1971 | Fox Chapel | 32-14 | W | A | |
| 125 | 10/8/1971 | Churchill | 0-6 | L | H | |
| 126 | 10/15/1971 | Sto-Rox | 40-0 | W | H | |
| 127 | 10/23/1971 | North Allegheny | 7-12 | L | A | |
| 128 | 10/29/1971 | North Hills | 34-7 | W | A | |
| 129 | 11/5/1971 | Shaler | 28-0 | W | H | |
| 130 | 9/9/1972 | Seneca Valley | 14-12 | W | A | |
| 131 | 9/15/1972 | Steel Valley | 41-0 | W | H | |
| 132 | 9/22/1972 | East Allegheny | 29-0 | W | A | |
| 133 | 9/29/1972 | Fox Chapel | 27-0 | W | H | |
| 134 | 10/7/1972 | Churchill | 43-0 | W | A | |
| 135 | 10/13/1972 | Sto-Rox | 24-13 | W | A | |
| 136 | 10/20/1972 | North Allegheny | 17-0 | W | H | |
| 137 | 10/27/1972 | North Hills | 20-18 | W | H | 2 TD's in the 4th quarter to win |
| 138 | 11/3/1972 | Shaler | 15-0 | W | A | |
| 139 | 11/17/1972 | Kiski Area | 22-13 | W | N | Game played at Three Rivers Stadium WPIAL AA Semi Final. First game at Three Rivers Stadium. |
| 140 | 11/25/1972 | Jeannette | 20-0 | W | N | Game played at Pitt Stadium WPIAL AA Final |
| 141 | 9/8/1973 | Steel Valley | 2-0 | W | A | Forfeit win due to strike at Steel Valley |
| 142 | 9/14/1973 | Highlands | 21-8 | W | H | |
| 143 | 9/22/1973 | Fox Chapel | 20-0 | W | A | |
| 144 | 9/28/1973 | Churchill | 46-0 | W | H | |
| 145 | 10/6/1973 | Sto-Rox | 31-10 | W | H | Rare Saturday home game |
| 146 | 10/13/1973 | North Allegheny | 7-13 | L | A | |
| 147 | 10/19/1973 | North Hills | 21-0 | W | A | |
| 148 | 10/26/1973 | Shaler | 41-0 | W | H | |
| 149 | 11/2/1973 | Seneca Valley | 20-6 | W | H | |
| 150 | 11/9/1973 | Penn Hills | 22-6 | W | N | Game played at Johnstown Point Stadium WPIAL AAA Quarterfinal / Great "Snow Game" |
| 151 | 11/17/1973 | New Castle | 15-22 | L | N | Game played at Pitt Stadium WPIAL AAA Semi Final |
| 152 | 9/6/1974 | Steel Valley | 50-0 | W | H | First time scoring 50 points |
| 153 | 9/13/1974 | Highlands | 36-6 | W | A | |
| 154 | 9/20/1974 | Fox Chapel | 33-0 | W | H | |
| 155 | 9/28/1974 | Churchill | 55-0 | W | A | |
| 156 | 10/5/1974 | Sto-Rox | 39-6 | W | A | |
| 157 | 10/11/1974 | North Allegheny | 37-0 | W | H | |
| 158 | 10/18/1974 | North Hills | 25-7 | W | H | |
| 159 | 10/25/1974 | Shaler | 26-3 | W | A | |
| 160 | 11/2/1974 | Seneca Valley | 43-19 | W | A | |
| 161 | 11/16/1974 | New Castle | 20-12 | W | N | Game played at Pitt Stadium WPIAL AAA Semi-Final |
| 162 | 11/16/1974 | Penn Hills | 13-0 | W | N | Game played at Valley Stadium WPIAL AAA Quarterfinal / 9,800 fans at Valley Stadium |
| 163 | 11/24/1974 | Upper St. Clair | 6-6 | T | N | Game played at Pitt Stadium WPIAL AAA Final |
| 164 | 9/5/1975 | McKeesport | 21-14 | W | H | |
| 165 | 9/13/1975 | Churchill | 21-7 | W | A | |
| 166 | 9/20/1975 | North Allegheny | 8-10 | L | A | |
| 167 | 9/26/1975 | Steel Valley | 37-0 | W | H | |
| 168 | 10/3/1975 | Pittsburgh Central Catholic | 0-0 | T | H | First game ever against PCC |
| 169 | 10/10/1975 | Highlands | 6-7 | L | A | |
| 170 | 10/17/1975 | North Hills | 0-14 | L | H | |
| 171 | 10/24/1975 | Seneca Valley | 37-0 | W | H | |
| 172 | 10/31/1975 | Shaler | 23-0 | W | A | |
| 173 | 9/11/1976 | McKeesport | 20-7 | W | A | |
| 174 | 9/17/1976 | Churchill | 8-3 | W | H | |
| 175 | 9/24/1976 | North Allegheny | 10-7 | W | H | |
| 176 | 10/2/1976 | Steel Valley | 7-13 | L | A | |
| 177 | 10/9/1976 | Pittsburgh Central Catholic | 25-0 | W | A | |
| 178 | 10/18/1976 | Highlands | 7-7 | T | H | Game postponed from 10/15/1976 due to rain |
| 179 | 10/22/1976 | North Hills | 14-0 | W | A | |
| 180 | 10/30/1976 | Seneca Valley | 35-0 | W | A | |
| 181 | 11/5/1976 | Shaler | 28-0 | W | H | |
| 182 | 11/12/1976 | South Allegheny | 26-14 | W | N | Game played at Jeannette Stadium WPIAL AAA Quarterfinal |
| 183 | 11/20/1976 | Penn Hills | 16-17 | L | N | Game played at Pitt Stadium WPIAL AAA Semi-Final |
| 184 | 9/2/1977 | East Allegheny | 0-0 | T | H | Game not played due to teacher strike at EA |
| 185 | 9/9/1977 | North Hills | 23-0 | W | H | |
| 186 | 9/17/1977 | North Allegheny | 7-0 | W | A | |
| 187 | 9/23/1977 | North Catholic | 27-13 | W | H | |