The following is a listing of the years, opponents, and results from years where the Gators met the same team more than once.
1982 - 10 games - 9 opponents
| 9/17/1982 | Butler | 7-13 | L | H | |
| 11/19/1982 | Butler | 6-22 | L | A | Game played at Valley Stadium WPIAL AAAA Semi Finals |
1983 - 11 games - 10 opponents
| 9/16/1983 | Butler | 6-14 | L | A | |
| 11/11/1983 | Butler | 7-13 | L | A | Game played at Butler Stadium WPIAL AAAA Quarterfinal |
1985 - 13 games - 12 opponents
| 9/13/1985 | Butler | 21-6 | W | H | |
| 11/15/1985 | Butler | 32-3 | W | N | Game played at Valley Stadium WPIAL AAAA Semi Final. Huge Crowd. Butler Coach Bernardi retires after game ends. |
1987 - 11 games - 10 opponents
| 9/19/1987 | North Allegheny | 24-0 | W | A | |
| 1987 | North Allegheny | 6-10 | L |
2002 - 12 games - 10 opponents
| 10/25/2002 | Franklin Regional | 16-0 | W | H | |
| 11/8/2002 | Franklin Regional | 28-14 | W | H | WPIAL AAAA Quarterfinals |
| 9/6/2002 | Woodland Hills | 7-28 | L | A | |
| 11/15/2002 | Woodland Hills | 17-34 | L | N | Game played at Franklin Regional WPIAL Semi-Finals |
2003 - 11 games - 10 opponents
| 9/12/2003 | Ringgold | 47-0 | W | A | |
| 10/31/2003 | Ringgold | 55-7 | W | H | WPIAL AAAA First Round |
2004 - 13 games - 11 opponents
| 8/27/2004 | Pittsburgh Central Catholic | 20-28 | L | H | GHS Stadium dedicated to former Coach Antimarino |
| 11/20/2004 | Pittsburgh Central Catholic | 0-28 | L | N | Game played at Heinz Field 1st ever game at Heinz field. Gateway in the championship game for the first time since 1986. PCC goes on to win the PIAA AAAA title and is regarded as one of the best ever AAAA teams. PCC beats Gateway twice in one season. |
| 9/4/2004 | Woodland Hills | 47-6 | W | H | 1st ever Gateway Kickoff Classic |
| 11/5/2004 | Woodland Hills | 31-12 | W | N | Game played at Norwin Stadium WPIAL AAAA Quarterfinals. Packed house at Norwin. |
2006 - 11 games - 10 opponents
| 10/13/2006 | Penn Hills | 7-41 | L | A | |
| 11/10/2006 | Penn Hills | 37-44 | L | N | Game played at Norwin Stadium WPIAL Quarterfinal / One of the most exciting games in Gateway History. Only time Penn Hills was played twice in one season. |
2008 - 13 games - 12 opponents
| 8/29/2008 | Penn Hills | 45-17 | W | H | Gateway jumps 31-3 halftime lead. RB Brian Williams rushes for 210 yards and also gets a 42 yard punt return for TD. First game for new Penn Hills coach Ron Graham. Packed stadium. Game televised live on PCN-TV and Comcast, covered by KDKA, WTAE, WPXI and FSN. |
| 11/14/2008 | Penn Hills | 38-23 | W | N | Game played at West Mifflin WPIAL PLAYOFFS Semi-Final. Gators take the lead 2 minutes into game and never look back. Dorian Bell rushes for 121 yards and 1 TD, Brian Williams adds 85 yards and 2 TD's. Corey Brown catches 2 TD passes from QB Kalkstein who passed for 150 yards. Gateway led 21-9 at halftime. First time Gateway beat Penn Hills twice in one season. |

name: Dayonne Nunley
jersey: #5 (CAPTAIN)
position: DB/RB/WR
height (wt): 5-8 (170)
year: Senior