|1||9/13/1958||24-7||W||A||1st game / 1st Victory|
|10||9/14/1968||7-0||W||A||Game played at 10:30am|
|11||9/12/1969||22-6||W||A||Moved to NA due to Teachers Strike|
|22||9/5/1980||0-0||-||Did not play due to Gateway teacher strike|
|27||9/7/1985||14-0||W||A||Hot sunny day|
|31||1990||0-55||L||worst ever loss to NA|
|39||11/16/2007||28-27||W||N||Game played at Wolvarena Stadium Turtle Creek
WPIAL AAAA Semi-Final. Gateway comes from behind then stops 2 point conversion attempt in OT to win the game.
|40||11/18/2011||17-21||L||N||Game played at Fox Chapel
Despite losing 14-0 at the half, the Gators pounded back and scored 17 unanswered points to take a 17-14 lead with around 8 minutes left in the game. N.A. took the ensuing kickoff and started driving downfield, and on a 3rd and 10 play from the Gators 40, the Gators intercepted the N.A. pass but were flagged for a phantom pass-interference call, giving the Tigers a first down on the Gators 20. They proceeded to wind down the clock and score with 43 seconds remaining to win the game. On the 2nd play of the game Gators QB Woodson suffered a shoulder injury and was unable to throw the ball the rest of the game. He sat out until halftime and played the 2nd half. Also RB Franklin reinjured his right knee during a big run in the 3rd quarter and was lost for the rest of the game. The depth of N.A. certainly helped a bit in this game - they dressed around 100 players to the Gators 40. It was a tough way to end the season for the Gators.